The Dispatch’s Sarah Isgur points out — in response to more than a few conservatives who are clamoring for Samuel Alito and/or Clarence Thomas to retire while there’s still a Republican Senate majority to confirm their replacements — that there is technically no need for either justice to retire before year's end. Alito won't retire in the lame duck and he doesn't need to. Trump can nominate someone to the Supreme Court and the senate can confirm without a vacancy. Then Trump can wait to sign the commission any time in the next two years. The question isn't Alito, its Cornyn/Tillis/Thune. Notice: We’re moving to a new subscription system and building a new NationalReview.com to make subscribing, reading and managing your account easier. While we finish the work, we’re unable to take orders. This year’s election conjures up memories of several similar defeats for the right. Voters in multiple states fought back against wealth and property taxes, men in women’s sports, and noncitizen voting.
Replacing Alito or Thomas in the Lame-Duck Session Would Guarantee Democratic Court-Packing
courtsFull text
Court synopsis, visualized
Drawn from this record · not a story you write
The LegalLens Gazette
Vol. Ink · No. 839
Cover · Page 1
Replacing Alito or Thomas in the Lame-Duck Session Would Guarantee Democratic Court-Packing
LegalLens Gazette · visual synopsis of the public record · not legal advice
Why this matters to you
Awaiting more reportingA headline alone cannot establish who is affected or what action follows. Open the source for the full context, dates, and supporting documents.
Read the original reportingHow to read this story
- Know the stage
- A proposal is a suggested change; adoption and commencement are separate steps. An allegation is a claim, not a finding. Check which stage the report describes.
- Check the scope
- Jurisdiction means the area or authority involved. A rule may apply only to certain places, people, or situations; look for eligibility conditions and exceptions.
